Top cards by price
Starter 1999 Chase Cards: Top 10 Most Valuable
S99 · Starter ·1999-07-01 · Other 1999 sets
These are the ten most valuable Starter 1999 cards by current USD market price. Grim Tutor currently leads the set at $95.62. For a mainline Magic release, the leaders usually combine constructed demand, Commander play and collector interest in the exact printing.
Ranked by the exact printing, not by card name across all sets. Prices move with the market; data last updated 2026-04-17.
Top 10 of Starter 1999
The current chase cards in Starter 1999, ranked by non-foil USD market price.
10 cards
- 1
Grim Tutor
S99 rare
$95.62
- 2
Piracy
S99 rare
$53.54
- 3
Time Warp
S99 rare
$38.31
- 4
Devastation
S99 rare
$17.70
- 5
Armageddon
S99 rare
$14.13
- 6
Righteous Fury
S99 rare
$11.49
- 7
Thunder Dragon
S99 rare
$11.00
- 8
Goblin Settler
S99 uncommon
$7.29
- 9
Nature's Cloak
S99 rare
$6.75
- 10
Goblin General
S99 uncommon
$6.59
How the ranking works
Price is attached to the printing.
A Magic card can appear in many sets, finishes and frame treatments. This list uses the individual Starter 1999 printing and ranks the available non-foil USD price for that printing. It does not transfer the price of an older or rarer version onto this set.
A chase card is simply one of the cards collectors currently pursue most strongly in this release. Competitive play, Commander demand, rarity and premium art can all affect the order, and a future reprint can change it.
Set questions
About Starter 1999 chase cards.
What is the most valuable card in Starter 1999?
Grim Tutor is currently the highest-priced card in this ranking at $95.62. Prices can change after each market update.
Are foil prices included?
No. The order uses the regular USD market price so that a single premium finish does not distort the set-wide comparison.
How often can the top ten change?
Any market update can change the ranking. New deck results, Commander demand and reprints are common reasons for movement.